Archive 1997–2024

ATI Radeon Xpress 200: Performance, PCI Express & DX9 for Athlon 64


ATI X800 XT: MSI K8N Neo2 vs. ATI Bullhead

The MSI K8N Neo2 was our Gold Editors Choice in our Socket 939 Roundup. We first compared the ATI RX480 Bullhead to the MSI running the same Athlon 64 3800+ CPU and the same 2-2-2-10 DDR memory. An ATI XT X800 AGP video card was used for the nForce3 Ultra testing while an X800XT PCIe was used for the ATI Bullhead.

MSI K8N Neo2 vs. ATI Bullhead
ATI X800 XT (AGP and PCIe), 3800+, 2X512 2-2-2-10 DDR
Benchmark MSI K8N Neo2
nVidia nForce 3
ATI Bullhead
ATI RX480
% Change
MSI to ATI
PCMark 2004 4880 4812 -1.4%
Aquamark 3 65620 65070 -0.8%
Doom3 - High Quality 85.9 87.3 +1.6%
Far Cry 1.1 151.4 159.0 +5.0%

In many graphics roundups we have seen no real performance difference in AGP and PCI Express versions of the same card. Therfore, we are comparing the ATI RX480 performance to nForce3 Ultra. The % variation is negligible except for Far Cry, where the ATI Bullhead is about 5% faster. As reported at AnandTech in past video reviews, nVidia PCIe is not as well-optimized for Far Cry as ATI. However, it looks like the problem is not just the nVidia PCIe, since the ATI card also is slower on the nVidia chipset than on ATI RX480.

Since the Far Cry issue is known, and will be clearer in other benchmarks reported here, we conclude that the ATI Bullhead and MSI K8N Neo2 are equivalent in performance.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1537 (Wayback Machine).