Archive 1997–2024

Fall 2004 DVDR Roundup: Dual Layer and 16X DVD+R


Write Quality Tests MKM 001

Dual layer media follows the same rules as single layer, but there are certain points on the disc where errors are known to occur the most. We have noticed that the part of the disc where the transition from layer to layer happens is where the PO errors have shown up. Our results are as follows:

PO Errors in MKM 001 2.4X DVD+R DL Media

We didn't have much luck getting dual layer media both to burn on all drives, since the Sony DRU-710A and MSI DR16-B had trouble writing a successful dual layer disc, and if there was success, to be recognized on the Plextor drive. The DVR-108D and DW1620 came out clean with 0 PO errors each with NEC following with 3 PO errors. The SOHW-1633S was another drive we had luck with, but a successful write was the end of it. PO errors on the dual layer media from that drive hit 192 and were all located between the 2GB and 4GB mark where there were also a few million PI errors!

PI Errors in MKM 001 2.4X DVD+R DL Media


The DVR-108D performed exceptionally well producing on 546 PI errors on the MKM 001 media. NEC followed with 261224 PI errors which held it and the Pioneer unit at the top two spots.

The Q-Tools screenshot of LiteOn's burn shows the majority PI errors between the 2GB and 4GB range.


It's too bad that there were only 4 drives on which we could test write qualities. Hopefully, future firmware releases will fix compatibility issues on the drives that we have tested in order for media to be recognized correctly on a wider range of hardware.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1528 (Wayback Machine).