Archive 1997–2024

5 Megapixels for < $300: Kodak DX4530, Olympus C-50 Zoom, Casio QV-R51


The Timing Tests

* NOTE: For all of our time tests, the cameras were reset to their factory default settings and then set to the highest recording resolution and quality. The Kodak and Casio cameras were loaded with a PNY 512MB SD card and the Olympus was loaded with a Fujifilm 256MB xD-Picture Card.

Shutter Lag

Before reading our results, please refer to our Testing Procedures page. For our shutter lag test, we performed 2 separate tests on each camera. For the first test, we pre-focused the lens and then measured the amount of time it took for the camera to take a picture after we pressed the shutter button. For the second test, we included the focusing time in our measurement to record a more general "lag" time. This is the time it takes the camera to focus and take a picture.

   Shutter Lag excluding focus (seconds)  Shutter Lag including focus (seconds)
Kodak DX4530 .07 .81
Olympus C-50 Zoom ‹ .05 .73
Casio QV-R51 ‹ .05 .27

As you can see, the difference between all 3 cameras for the pre-focused times was very small. This difference was not even noticeable when using the cameras. The real issue is how fast the cameras were able to focus and take a picture. The Casio QV-R51 beat the Kodak and Olympus hands down with an average time of .27 sec. This gave the Casio a very responsive feeling when taking a picture. After pushing the shutter button, the Kodak camera was the slowest to shoot with an average of .81 sec. and the Olympus was just a little bit faster at .73 sec. In short, the Casio camera was really the best performer in terms of shutter lag and general shooting lag.

Startup Time

The startup time for each camera is recorded from the moment the power button is pushed to the moment the camera's shutter sounds.

   Startup time (seconds)
Kodak DX4530 6.02
Olympus C-50 Zoom 5.70
Casio QV-R51 2.58

Again, Casio is the clear winner in our startup time test. The Kodak and Olympus cameras really take their time extending their lenses after the power is turned on. If you were trying to capture a moment as fast as possible, the Kodak and the Olympus could really be irritating.

Write Times

We recorded 4 different types of write times: Single shot, Shot to shot, Shot to shot w/flash, and Shot to shot w/buffer full.

Single Shot - The time it takes for a single picture to be completely written to the flash card
Shot To Shot (STS) - The time until the second shot is able to be taken after the first
Shot To Shot w/flash - The time it takes for the camera to take two pictures with the flash, starting from the moment the first flash is fired to the moment the second is fired
Shot To Shot (Buffer Full) - The time until the camera is able to take another shot after the in-camera buffer is full

We set the cameras to their highest quality JPG setting and ran the same 4 tests on each camera 3 times and averaged the results. If the cameras offered an uncompressed setting, we ran both the tests with both JPG and uncompressed settings. First, we'll start with the JPG write times. Below are the resolution and quality settings for each camera.

JPG Times

 Camera Settings (JPG)
Kodak DX4530 JPG, 2580x1932; Avg. file size = 880KB
Olympus C-50 Zoom JPG, 2560x1920; Avg. file size = 2MB
Casio QV-R51 JPG fine, 2560x1920; Avg. file size = 900KB

 Results (in seconds)
   Single Shot  Shot To Shot  Shot To Shot w/Flash  Shot To Shot w/Buffer Full
Kodak DX4530 9.02 2.52 2.54 4.32
Olympus C-50 Zoom 2.93 3.50 7.78 Same as STS
Casio QV-R51 2.90 4.24 8.51 Same as STS

Although Kodak has a 9.02 sec. time for the Single Shot test, we were able to take 6 pictures in a row at 1 frame every 2.52 sec. There is not a dedicated "disk activity" light on the DX4530, so we measured the time that the green "ready" light was blinking after a picture was taken. The DX4530 outperformed both the Olympus and the Casio for Shot to Shot, Shot to Shot w/Flash, and Shot to Shot w/Buffer Full times. The Olympus and Casio cameras were exceptionally slow for Shot to Shot w/Flash times. Although the Olympus and Casio cameras performed worse than the Kodak camera for the first 6 pictures, it is worth noting that after the 6th picture, the C-50 Zoom and the QV-R51 still shot at their usual Shot to Shot time while the DX4530 slowed down to 4.32 sec. So, the Kodak camera is going to perform better if you want to take 6 pictures in a row (with or without flash) while the Olympus and Casio cameras will do a little bit better for more continuous shooting.

Uncompressed Times

 Camera Settings (Uncompressed)
Kodak DX4530 N/A
Olympus C-50 Zoom TIFF, 2560x1920; Avg. file size = 15MB
Casio QV-R51 N/A

 Results (in seconds)
   Single Shot  Shot To Shot  Shot To Shot w/Flash  Shot To Shot w/Buffer Full
Kodak DX4530 N/A N/A N/A N/A
Olympus C-50 Zoom 21.22 25.25 25.28 Same as STS
Casio QV-R51 N/A N/A N/A N/A

Since the C-50 Zoom was the only camera to offer an uncompressed recording mode, we don't have much for comparison here. However, it should be obvious that 25 seconds between shots is totally unacceptable for any camera. It is nice to have the option to shoot uncompressed, but almost useless at this speed.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1391 (Wayback Machine).