Intel's 925X & LGA-775: Are Prescott 3.6 and PCI Express Graphics any Faster?
- Posted in
- CPUs
PCI Express Graphics Cards
Both ATI and NVIDIA supplied cards for Intel's 925X/915 launch; NVIDIA provided NV45s (PCI Express GeForce 6800 Ultras) while ATI provided R423s (PCI Express Radeon X800 XTs).There is a major difference between both ATI's and NVIDIA's approach to PCI Express graphics that has been the debate between the two companies for the past several months. ATI built brand new GPUs with a PCI Express x16 interface in the core to support the new standard, meaning that for every GPU that they want to have a PCI Express version of, ATI has to have a separate GPU design. Granted that the differences between a R420 (AGP 8X X800) and R423 (PCI Express X800) on a design level are minimal, they are still two separate chips. ATI's PCI Express strategy, basically, increases dramatically the number of GPUs that they have to manufacture, but it also guarantees the highest possible performance.
NVIDIA, on the other hand, takes a more economical approach from a manufacturing standpoint and will continue to only make AGP 8X compliant GPUs. In order to satisfy the PCI Express market, NVIDIA will outfit their PCI Express cards with an AGP-to-PCI Express bridge chip that NVIDIA calls their High Speed Interconnect (HSI). The bridge chip means that NVIDIA can still produce the same number of GPUs; just toss on a bridge chip whenever those GPUs need to be put on PCI Express cards.
NVIDIA will eventually offer native PCI Express GPUs, at which point, they will continue to use the HSI as necessary to bridge back to AGP for older platforms. Considering that it will take years for AGP to go away completely, this solution isn't a bad one at all.
The obvious downside to NVIDIA's approach is that the additional bridge could offer a performance penalty, but the question is how much? That is what we're going to answer now...
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1361 (Wayback Machine).