The Return of 2-2-2: Corsair 3200XL & Samsung PC4000
- Posted in
- Memory
Intel Test Results: Samsung PC4000
| Samsung PC4000 (DDR500) - 2 x 256Mb Single-Sided | |||||
| Speed | Memory Timings & Voltage | Quake3 fps | Sandra UNBuffered | Sandra Standard Buffered | Super PI 2M places (time in sec) |
| 400DDR 800FSB |
2-2-2-5 2.5VV |
323.4 | INT 2700 FLT 2738 |
INT 4509 FLT 4506 |
131 |
| 433DDR 866FSB |
2-2-3-5 2.65V |
344.7 | INT 2775 FLT 2825 |
INT 4835 FLT 4837 |
122 |
| 466DDR 933FSB |
2-3-3-6 2.65V |
365.6 | INT 2853 FLT 2880 |
INT 5163 FLT 5163 |
115 |
| 500DDR 1000FSB |
3-3-3-7 2.75V |
383.1 | INT 2961 FLT 3029 |
INT 5450 FLT 55449 |
109 |
| 506DDR 1048FSB |
3-4-4-7 2.85V |
- | - | - | - |
Since the Samsung PC4000 is using the same memory chips as the Corsair 3200XL, the lower performance has to be attributed to other factors. Corsair is using a different PCB and different SPD timings, which improve the Corsair performance. In addition, 2 single-sided DIMMs perform poorer than 2 double-sided DIMMs on the Intel platform, which is even stated in Intel white papers. Third, 512MB in 2 DIMMs is not as fast in some benchmarks as 1GB in 2 DIMMs.
The Samsung results should not be considered as a fair performance comparison. Rather, the results clearly demonstrate the penalty of 2 single-sided versus 2 double-sided DIMMs on an Intel test bed. Credit should also be given to Corsair for the excellent quality of their PCB and SPD design used on 3200XL.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1352 (Wayback Machine).