Archive 1997–2024

Q2 2004 Desktop Hard Drive Comparison: WD Raptor vs the World

Pure Hard Disk Performance

Although the point of our test suite is to focus on real world performance, it is useful to look at some theoretical numbers in order to get an idea of drive superiority.

To measure "pure" hard disk performance, we took a real world benchmark - in this case, the entire Winstone 2004 suite - and used Intel's IPEAK utility to capture a trace file of all of the IO operations that take place during a single run of Business Winstone 2004 and MCC Winstone 2004. We then use IPEAK to play back the trace, much like a timedemo, on each of the hard drives, which gives us a mean service time in milliseconds; in other words, the average time that each drive took to fulfill each IO operation.

In order to make the data more understandable, we report the scores as an average number of IO operations per second so that higher scores translate into better performance.

Keep in mind that these performance scores are best only for comparing pure hard disk performance, and in no way do they reflect the actual real world performance impact of these hard drives.

For descriptions of what the Business and Multimedia Content Creation Winstone 2004 tests consist of, reference those benchmark pages.

IPEAK Business Winstone 2004 - Pure Hard Disk Performance

We see from the Business Winstone IPEAK scores that the two Raptor drives are, by far, the highest performers out of the bunch.

As our focus shifts down to the 7200RPM 8MB cache drives, we see that they all offer similar performance. In this case, the Western Digital WD1200JB and the Maxtor DiamondMax Plus 9 offer basically identical performance. The Seagate Barracuda 7200.7 falls behind somewhat, but what matters most is how these drives perform in the real world.

Looking at the older IBM 75GXP and Maxtor D740X drives, it's interesting to see that the fastest drives of today are around twice as fast as the fastest drives from a few years ago.

IPEAK Content Creation Winstone 2004 - Pure Hard Disk Performance

As we look at Multimedia Content Creation IPEAK performance, we see that the two Raptors continue to maintain a significant performance advantage over the competition. There is a bit of place switching as the Seagate 7200.7 and WD 1200JB perform much closer, with the Maxtor DiamondMax Plus 9 holding a bit of a lead.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1343 (Wayback Machine).