Archive 1997–2024

Samsung 172X: 12ms Response Time for 17" LCD


Subjective Analysis


 DisplayMate/CheckScreen/VESA FPDM 2.0
 Test  Monitor  Observations
Intensity range check 172X (digital) 5, Good
172X (analog) 5
2001FP (digital) 5
2001FP (analog) 5, Good
Black level adjustment 172X (digital) 4.5
172X (analog) 4.5
2001FP (digital) 4.5
2001FP (analog) 4.5, Acceptable
Defocusing, blooming and halos check 172X (digital) 5, None
172X (analog) 5
2001FP (digital) 5, None
2001FP (analog) 5, None
Screen uniformity and color purity 172X (digital) 5, Excellent
172X (analog) 5
2001FP (digital) 4.5+
2001FP (analog) 4.5+, better than 192T, but still small imperfection on upper right
Dark screen (Glare Test) 172X (digital)
4, Similar to Samsung 192T
172X (analog)
4
2001FP (digital)
4.5
2001FP (analog)
4.5, Improvement over 1702FP and 192T
Primary colors 172X (digital) 4.5
172X (analog) 4.5
2001FP (digital) 4
2001FP (analog) 4, attempted to fix curves with OptiCal
Color Scales 172X (digital) 4.5
172X (analog) 4.5
2001FP (digital) 4, red errors
2001FP (analog) 4, red errors
16 intensity levels 172X (digital) 5, Excellent
172X (analog) 5
2001FP (digital) 4.5+
2001FP (analog) 4.5+, Improvement over the 192T
Screen regulation 172X (digital) 5
172X (analog) 4.5, Imperfections along edges
2001FP (digital) 5
2001FP (analog) 4.5
Streaking and ghosting 172X (digital) 5, none
172X (analog) 3, Intense streaking on simple images
2001FP (digital) 5, None
2001FP (analog) 3.5, Extremely present at 1600x1200. Analog signal is not capable.

Our first surprise came when we noticed how poorly the 172X held the analog signal. Any imperfections from the analog signal seemed only amplified by the TN display. Below is a streaking artifact generated by a simple alternating white/black column test pattern (Moire Column Pattern). The effect looks like a viewing angle imperfection in the still image, but careful analysis shows the streaking occurs no matter what viewing angle. The streaking only appears on the left and right sides of the screen, not the middle.



Click to enlarge.


The monitor had particular issues with non-solid half tones. We suspect that this is related to the FRC dithering.

Using the Entertainment display mode in MagicBright, we achieved excellent intensity range and primary color tests. After correcting the image with OptiCal in the first half of this review, there were few instances where the color depth was unacceptable. However, we are capable of noticing the FRC enabled LCD versus a native 16.7M color panel; occasionally, the dithering creates patches of interference where the dithering should occur. This appears most frequently on the analog input, but is also present on the digital input. Fortunately, most people should be unable to detect these imperfections.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1342 (Wayback Machine).