Apple's In-Ear Headphones and Sony's MDR-EX71SL - Searching for Decent In-Ear Headphones
- Posted in
- Smartphones
- Mobile
Apple's In-Ear and Sony's MDR-EX71SL: In-Ear Fitting
Both of the in-ear headphones come with three sizes of earpieces. With headband style headphones, the emitting stereo piece remains on the outside of the ear, so there is no need to be concerned about size of comfort, other than to use audio matting material. Once you get to in-ear headphones, it is obvious that the size of the ear canal varies between people, and thus, the only way to please everyone is to either customize the sizes or standardize them. The latter is obviously preferred, since customization would become incredibly expensive and the variance among the general population is still minimal at best.Our conclusion based on use is that the medium-sized earpieces for these two fit well for the 16- to 25-age bracket, but the Apple may be a more comfortable fit, since the Sony definition of medium is an iota larger than we would like. Thus, our finding is that the sizes don't really match up in size per say, but rather they overlap.
Sizes from smallest to largest:
- Sony MDR-EX71SL small
- Apple In-ear small
- Apple In-ear medium
- Sony MDR-EX71SL medium
- Apple In-Ear large
- Sony MDR-EX71SL large
Changing earpieces became one of our design concerns because the last thing that you want is to overstretch or damage one of the small rubber earpieces, since the buyer may want to change later on. Sony's design is simpler as the rubber pieces can just be shimmied on and off the earbud, though fitting is a bit harder than removal because the tip is slightly enlarged.
Apple's In-Ear headphones are basically the same plus the security tab design. On the earbud, there is a small groove for the security tab on the earpiece to fit snugly in. This is two-fold: one, the earbuds are angled, so this helps position the earpiece correctly; and second, it offers additional security so that the earpiece doesn't fall out.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1341 (Wayback Machine).



