Archive 1997–2024

The Toshiba XG6 1TB SSD Review: Our First 96-Layer 3D NAND SSD

Conclusion

The Toshiba XG6 only makes one major change over last year's XG5 by introducing 96-layer 3D NAND, so the product as a whole is mostly an incremental improvement. The XG6 builds upon the XG5 in almost every way with no significant regressions in performance or power efficiency, so it is very easy for OEMs to drop in the XG6 as a replacement for any devices where they are shipping the XG5.

The most significant improvements the XG6 offers over the XG5 show up on some of our more difficult benchmarks, where the XG6 is much faster at mixed random read/write workloads and full-drive performance in general. The XG5 was already a very well-rounded drive with a great combination of performance and power efficiency, and the XG6 only broadens that appeal by shoring up the most significant weaknesses of the XG5. It is rare for a drive to be so free of obvious flaws.

The Toshiba XG5 was the first high-performance NVMe SSD that could match or exceed the power efficiency of most SATA SSDs, meaning that it was no longer necessary to sacrifice battery life to get the improved peak performance of NVMe. Since then, some of the power efficiency records have been beaten by TLC-based NVMe SSDs with newer controllers. The WD Black did the most to raise the bar for power efficiency, but some of the entry-level NVMe alternatives that have appeared are also quite a bit more efficient that the typical high-end drive. The Toshiba XG6 either retakes the lead or comes close enough to effectively tie the competition in every one of our power efficiency measurements.

The only significant downside to the Toshiba XG6 is that it never really improves upon Toshiba's performance enough to set records; it cannot match the peak performance offered by some of the top consumer NVMe drives currently on the market. Toshiba would have a hard time selling the XG6 as a retail product for enthusiasts who are seeking the bragging rights of the fastest storage money can buy. But the XG6 is an OEM drive and performs well enough to give any notebook a credible claim to offering high-end storage. If your next notebook purchase includes an XG6, there would be absolutely no need to upgrade it with any current retail SSD unless a 2TB drive was needed. The WD Black is the only drive that could offer better performance without sacrificing battery life, and it can't beat the XG6 across the board due to its subpar sequential read performance. (The WD Black's OEM counterpart WD SN720 is probably the most direct competition to the XG6, but I suspect the XG6 will offer lower costs to OEMs.)

If Toshiba can ramp up output of their 96L 3D TLC NAND quickly, I would like to see a retail version of the XG6. With a bit more firmware tweaking to improve peak performance, Toshiba could probably have a very cost-effective drive that would compete well against the cheapest 8-channel NVMe SSDs and remove the need for the DRAMless RC100 to serve as their low-cost NVMe drive. For the retail market where desktops play a much bigger role than in the OEM market, it would be appropriate to sacrifice some of their excess power efficiency to deliver higher performance, if their controller makes that possible. But if Toshiba isn't prepared to compete in that mid-level price range, they should wait until they have a faster controller to pair with their 96L NAND to match the peak performance numbers we are seeing from Silicon Motion, Western Digital and Samsung.

Without retail pricing it is difficult to judge the cost effectiveness of the XG6, but the 96L NAND should help Toshiba offer OEMs a bargain. There's no reason for OEMs to shy away from using the XG6 in their systems, and no reason for consumers to be disappointed if they find the XG6 inside their new system purchase.

As an aside, I'm strongly considering putting the XG6 into my personal laptop for a while. It's an older machine that only has a PCIe 2.0 link to the SSD so none of the XG6's performance deficiencies relative to the fastest drives on the market will make much difference, and the XG6 will probably offer the best battery life of any drive I have on hand.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/13254/the-toshiba-xg6-1tb-ssd-review-first-96l-3d-nand (Wayback Machine).