AMD Ryzen 5 2400G and Ryzen 3 2200G Core Frequency Scaling: An Analysis
APU Core Frequency Scaling
One of the holy grails in processor performance is higher clock speed. All things being told, if we exclude power consumption from the mix, most performance tools will prefer, in order, a high IPC, then a high frequency, and finally more cores. Building a magical processor with double the IPC or double the frequency (at the same power) would be a magnificent thing, and would usually be preferred to just adding cores, as cores can scale: IPC and frequency often does not.
The main issue with driving frequency is power consumption and process. We all remember the days of Pentium 4, where driving frequency led to disasterous heat output and power consumption, and Intel went back to the drawing board to work more on IPC. Processors today are often built around the notion of a peak efficiency point, and the design is geared towards that specific level of performance and power. Moving the frequency outside of that peak area can lead to drastic increases in power consumption, so a balance is made. We get cores down at 1W each, or large CPUs consuming 300W-500W depending on the industry the chip is designed for.
Once a CPU is designed and built, the main dial for adjusting performance is only the frequency. For the whole chip, this might be the frequency of the cores, or the frequency of the memory/memory controller, or the frequency of the graphics. For this article, we are concerned purely with the core frequency and performance. Predicting how well core performance scales with frequency requires an intimate knowledge of how the software processes instructions: if the program is all about raw compute throughput, then as long as the memory bandwidth can keep up, then a direct scaling factor can usually be observed. When the memory cannot keep up, or the storage is lacking, or other pathways are blocked, then the CPU performance is seen as identical no matter what the frequency.
In our CPU tests, we adjusted the frequency from 3.5 GHz to 4.0 GHz, testing at each 100 MHz level, for a total +14.3% frequency gain. In the results, the raw throughput tests such as Blender, POV-Ray, 3DPM, and Handbrake all had performance level gains around the 13-14% level, as you would expect with a direct frequency uplift, showing that these tests scale well. Our memory limited benchmarks, such as WinRAR and DigiCortex, only saw smaller gains, of 5% at best, though often not at all.
For gaming, predicting how the performance will change is quite difficult. Moving data over the PCIe bus is one thing, but it will come down to draw calls and the ability for the CPU to move textures and perform in-scene adjustments. We did tests on both the integrated graphics and using a discrete graphics card, the GTX 1060, which is around the price point that someone buying an APU is likely to invest into a discrete graphics card.
For our integrated graphics testing, where we normally expect to see improvements with overclocking the CPU, almost nothing happened (or within testing variance). Shadow of Mordor saw an uptick on the Ryzen 3 2200G, but that was more of an anomoly than a rule. The 99th percentile faired a bit better.
Thief was the best recipient of increasing the core clock for percentiles, with Ashes not far behind. Shadow of Mordor saw the same 7% gain or so with the 2200G.
On our discrete GPU, the improvements were more obvious:
Most combinations saw at least a 3% increase, although only Civilization 6 and Ashes on the 2200G approached a 13% increase consummate with the frequency uplift.
The scaling worked best with the 99th percentile frame rates, with almost every game seeing a 5% gain in performance, and a lot more with a 10-13% gain as well. Rise of the Tomb Raider, which always loves being the oddball in these cases, actually saw a benefit above and beyond a 14.3% frequency increase.
Overall, it would seem, overclocking an APU with just the core frequency in mind works best for pure CPU tests, and in the percentiles when using a discrete graphics card. Users that are more focused on integrated graphics should focus on the IGP frequency and the memory instead.
Recommended Reading
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/12516/amd-ryzen-2200g-2400g-cpu-core-frequency-scaling (Wayback Machine).




