Intel Developer Forum Spring 2004 - Day 1: Wider and Faster
- Posted in
- Trade Shows
Nocona and Prescott: Intel adopts x86-64
There was an incredible amount of speculation that Intel would make a formal announcement about their use of AMD's 64 bit extensions to the x86 ISA at IDF this week. Intel has indicated for a long while now that they would adopt 64 bit for the desktop "when it makes sense." Of course, the time frame we have been given for such a thing making sense has always been much further down the road than this year, and the tradition continues still. Even though Intel has announced that its Nocona (90nm Xeon) processor will have 64 bit x86 extensions enabled, they are targeting this squarely at the workstation/server market and have still not made the decision to move x86-64 to the desktop.It is the case that x86-64 can be released in a P4 form anytime Intel wants (though it may end up being later rather than sooner) since the Nocona processor is based on a Prescott core with its 64 bit hardware enabled in a Xeon package (and with Xeon sized caches and features). We are looking into the method with which Intel has disabled the 64 bit extensions in current versions of Prescott, but we don't have conclusive data as of yet. We suspect, though, that the extensions are disabled much the same way that clock speeds are locked (so that neither enthusiasts nor remarkers can add value not included straight from Intel).
As far as what is actually going on architecturally, we still need to do a little digging. We do know some things for fact. Intel's implementation of the x86-64 extensions will be completely compatible with AMD's. The extensions are in the current version of Prescott in a disabled state (and Intel is still determining an appropriate time to release a 64bit enabled P4).
We still have questions about Intel's ALU design and how it supports the new extensions, as well as whether or not Nocona will have a larger trace cache than Prescott. Needless to day, there are still plenty of things we don't know yet.
Up until last year (with the release of the Athlon64), Intel had four options for more accessible 64 bit computing: bring the Itanium's EPIC (Explicitly Parallel Instruction Computer) based IA-64 to the desktop, develop a desktop 64 bit ISA based around fast emulation of x86, create their own 64 bit extensions to the x86 architecture, or adopt AMD's extensions to x86 for their future processors. Let's take a look at these options to try to understand how we got here today.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1243 (Wayback Machine).