Intel 3.2E vs. 3.2EE vs. 3.2C: Comparing Baseline Performance
- Posted in
- CPUs
Final Words
The only goal of testing three different Intel 3.2 processors on the same reference motherboard was to establish benchmark results for future motherboard testing. However, it is hard not to compare the CPU performance differences in these tests. What perhaps stands out the most is that for all the negative press Prescott has received at launch, it is really a decent performer that is very close to Northwood, at least at the 3.2GHz speed. As Anand found in Intel's Pentium 4 E: Prescott Arrives with Luggage, Prescott scales faster than Northwood as speed increases. At 3.2GHz, performance is closer than we first thought it would be, and Prescott is certainly ahead of Northwood by the time you reach 3.7 to 3.8GHz.Looking at individual performance categories from our standard benchmarks, it is easier to understand why Intel introduced another EE chip in the 3.4 speed. The one area where Prescott is poorest is gaming performance, an area already dominated by the Athlon 64. Prescott is slower compared to Northwood in this area, but the real difference is 0% to 5% in most cases. Northwood is not a great game chip either compared to A64, so the 3.2EE and 3.4EE fill that void. Unfortunately, the cost of bringing Pentium 4 gaming performance to Athlon 64 levels is very high, with the EE chips selling for premium prices.
For our standard "real application" benchmarks, Multimedia Content Creation Winstone and Office Winstone, Prescott and Northwood performed virtually the same in these baseline tests. You will not notice the difference between these similarly-priced chips. P4EE performs best in these benchmarks, as expected, but at 3 times the price, the P4EE is not really in the same league with Prescott and Northwood.
The areas that most surprised us were Media Encoding and Workstation Performance. We expected P4EE to lead in these benchmarks, but instead, Prescott was the top performer. Intel tells us that Divx 5.1.1 provides support for new SSE3 instructions, and at least in our configuration with an XMpeg 5 front end, Prescott leads in Media Encoding. Other Media Encoding benchmarks that use older codecs have been showing Prescott about the same as Northwood in encoding tests. Workstation Performance was generally dominated by Prescott, so those applications that depend on the types of operations tested in SPECviewperf will perform best with the Prescott 3.2E. The SPECviewperf 7.1.1 benchmarks were repeated on a VIA PT880 motherboard with all three 3.2 processors, and Prescott again dominated these benches, providing the top performance in all the 7.1.1 suite including UGS.
Prescott and EE compatibility will be a part of all future testing of Pentium 4 motherboards. With the testing that went into this comparison, you should have a better idea of how the 3 flavors of Pentium 4 compare at the same speed on the same reference motherboard. Prescott is not a very good gaming chip at 3.2 GHz, but it is closer to Northwood than many expected. If you can afford the price tag, P4EE is still the best choice for gaming among Intel processors. Northwood and Prescott are virtually interchangeable as measured in Content Creation and General Usage performance. For Media Encoding and Workstation Performance, Prescott at 3.2GHz appears to have an edge over both Northwood and the much more expensive 3.2EE.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1238 (Wayback Machine).