Archive 1997–2024

The Samsung 860 PRO (512GB And 4TB) SSD Review: Replacing A Legend

Conclusion

By the numbers, the Samsung 860 PRO is generally the fastest SATA SSD, but the performance doesn't stand out from the crowd. The 860 PRO offers only slight improvements over the performance of the 850 PRO, and the better competing SATA SSDs are now able to perform at or near the level of the Samsung drives. The SATA interface is simply too much of a bottleneck for any SATA drive to distinguish itself with high performance on a broad range of tests. Hitting those limits is now expected from mainstream drives, instead of being an aspirational goal. Which means that while the 860 PRO is launching as the fastest SATA SSD on the market – once again retaining Samsung's traditional dominance of the market – its accomplishments feel mooted by the limitations of the SATA interface and how close the rest of the competition is these days.

The power consumption situation is quite different; there's plenty of room for improvement, and the 860 PRO delivers. The 850 PRO had been looking rather power-hungry lately as other drives approached its performance level without having to sacrifice as much power efficiency. With updated NAND and DRAM and controller, the 860 PRO is much more efficient than the 850 PRO, setting new records on tests where the Samsung drives still rated well, and catching up to most of the competition where the 850 PRO was notably inefficient.

The only aspect in which the Samsung 860 PRO has a clear and large advantage over the competition is the write endurance. The problem is that this does not matter. With the warranty period shortened to 5 years and the rated write endurance increased substantially over the 850 PRO, the 860 PRO's endurance rating comes out to 0.64 drive writes per day. It is genuinely hard to come up with a realistic non-server workload that produces a write volume equivalent to filling the entire drive every business day. Working with uncompressed video can certainly generate the terabytes of data needed to wear down an 860 PRO, but then the SATA bottleneck becomes significant. It may turn out that the only sensible reason to use an 860 PRO would be in a RAID array, and even then enterprise SSDs may offer a better balance of capacity, endurance, per-drive performance and cost.

SATA SSD Price Comparison
  240-275GB 480-525GB 960-1050GB 2TB 4TB
Samsung 860 PRO (MSRP) $139.99 (55¢/GB) $249.99 (49¢/GB) $479.99 (47¢/GB) $949.99 (46¢/GB) $1899.99 (46¢/GB)
Samsung 860 EVO (MSRP) $94.99 (38¢/GB) $169.99 (34¢/GB) $329.99 (33¢/GB) $649.99 (32¢/GB) $1399.99 (35¢/GB)
Samsung 850 EVO $102.44 (41¢/GB) $139.99 (28¢/GB) $299.99 (30¢/GB) $649.33 (32¢/GB) $1427.95 (36¢/GB)
Samsung 850 PRO $141.00 (55¢/GB) $217.99 (43¢/GB) $429.99 (42¢/GB) $892.09 (44¢/GB)  
Crucial MX500 $79.99 (32¢/GB) $134.95 (27¢/GB) $259.99 (26¢/GB) $499.99 (25¢/GB)  
Crucial BX300 $87.99 (37¢/GB) $144.99 (30¢/GB)      
Crucial MX300 $89.99 (33¢/GB) $146.99 (28¢/GB) $267.00 (25¢/GB) $549.99 (27¢/GB)  
SanDisk Ultra 3D $79.99 (32¢/GB) $129.99 (26¢/GB) $249.99 (25¢/GB) $499.99 (25¢/GB)  
WD Blue 3D NAND $79.99 (32¢/GB) $139.99 (28¢/GB) $274.79 (27¢/GB) $556.00 (28¢/GB)  
Toshiba TR200 $79.99 (33¢/GB)        
Intel 545s $99.99 (39¢/GB) $159.99 (31¢/GB)      

For more typical desktop and workstation usage patterns, the high endurance ratings of the Samsung 860 PRO are overkill, and so are the smaller ratings on the 860 EVO. Now that said – and least we see the pendulum swing the other way – having drives with plenty of write endurance is by and large a good thing, if only because it provides plenty of headroom for certain workloads and and some additional options on the market. The flip side of that however is that practically speaking, Samsung is offering a benefit that consumers don't need, and charging a substantial premium for it.

Ultimately the Samsung 860 PRO is a commendable technical achievement; Samsung has pushed the SATA III interface to its limit by having it serve such a powerful SSD, and it's entirely possible we won't see a better desktop SATA SSD ever made. But as SSDs get faster and faster and the SATA interface does not, I would argue that the 860 PRO isn't a very good product, at least not for the desktop SSD market of 2018. The market has moved on, and power users and enthusiasts who want something better than a mainstream SSD are all looking for PCIe SSDs. The Samsung 860 PRO is priced like a PCIe SSD, but offers none of the tangible advantages. And with the prices Samsung is planning on charging for the 860 family, I'm worried that at MSRP, even the 860 EVO is likely to be unconvincing.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/12348/the-samsung-860-pro-512gb-and-4tb-ssd-review (Wayback Machine).