Archive 1997–2024

Shuttle XPC ST61G4: Tiny Computer with Big Integrated Video


Shuttle XPC ST61G4: ATI 9100IGP Memory Performance

With the memory timings limited to 2-3-3-6 and performance as a chipset about 3% to 10% slower than Intel, Science Mark 2 memory benchmarks were run to try to determine the impact of the ATI chipset memory controller on system performance. While ATI has been able to deliver a Dual-Channel memory controller on the 9100IGP chipset, we suspected that the memory bandwidth and memory latency might be poorer than the performance we are seeing currently with Intel chipsets.


As suspected, Science Mark Memory Test reports the raw memory bandwidth of ATI's memory controller at about 80% the bandwidth of Intel's 865/875 chipset. With the deep pipes of the Pentium 4 design, memory bandwidth has been shown to be an important part of performance. Memory latency also can affect performance, and Science Mark shows ATI chipset latency about 50% higher than Intel 865/875.



It would be a mistake to consider these Science Mark 2 memory test results in isolation, since they are merely a couple of pieces of the total picture. However, these results suggest that ATI has more work to do on their memory controller to be fully competitive with the current solution from Intel and others. It should also be pointed out that ATI has made huge strides in the design of their memory controller in recent months, and this makes us excited to see the upcoming ATI chipsets.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1223 (Wayback Machine).