Athlon64 3400+: Part 2
- Posted in
- CPUs
Gaming and Media Encoding Performance
One of the biggest questions is how the $430 3400+ compares to the $750 Athlon64 FX51 in gaming. With both running at the same speed and the same 1Mb of cache, we can finally see what impact the different memory architectures have on performance. The only real difference in the 3400+ and the FX51 is, after all, the Dual-Channel Registered memory used in the FX51 versus the Single-Channel used for the 3400+. While the FX51 is still faster, the real difference between the 2 chips is next to nothing in X2 and Unreal Tournament Flyby. The Dual-Channel memory does make a larger difference in Media Encoding, Halo, and UT Botmatch. It is fair to say that at about 60% of the price of the FX51, the 3400+ performs very well indeed, coming very close in many gaming benchmarks.
It is interesting that all of the Athlon64 chips outperform the Intel Pentium 4 EE in gaming, except for the comparable performance in the older Quake 3. This again demonstrates the superiority of the A64 as a gaming platform. The one area where Intel dominates is Media Encoding, where the 3.2EE, 3.2 and even the 3.0 lead all Athlon64 family chips. While the Dual-Channel FX51 does compare much better to Intel in Media Encoding, the Intel P4 family is still the top choice for Media Encoding. Also, don't overlook the fact that the 3400+, in particular, and the Socket 754 A64's, in general, have made giant strides in Media Encoding performance compared to the older Athlon XP processors.
The Pentium 4EE does perform much better in gaming than the lower-priced 3.2 and 3.0, and the gap is much smaller when the Athlon64 is compared to the P4EE. However, unless your budget can handle $1000 for the CPU, the Athlon64 is your best choice for a gaming rig. In the Athlon64 family, the FX51 is the best performing processor in gaming, but it is also a pricey $750. The 3400+ provides most of the same gaming performance for about $430.
As we have seen in other recent GunMetal 2 tests, the benchmark seems to be video-card bound and it tells us very little about the performance differences in processors or systems. While GunMetal 2 may be useful for Video Card comparisons, it is not a good tool for processor or system performance measurements and will be dropped from future system testing.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1220 (Wayback Machine).