Archive 1997–2024

Image Quality Analysis Fall 2003: A Glance Through the Looking Glass


Unreal Tournament 2003




ATI (Click to enlarge.)




NVIDIA (Click to enlarge.)


These images are very similar. Even if we were to look at a different image and see some variation, there isn't a perceptible difference in the way each card renders this scene.



ATI 4xAA/8xAF (Click to enlarge.)




NVIDIA 4xAA/8xAF (Click to enlarge.)


Here, we have an 800% zoomed image in order to take a look at antialiasing. As we can see, both cards do a pretty good job of eliminating any jagged edges in this example, but we aren't looking at near horizontal or near vertical lines (which would look better with ATI's rotated grid antialiasing).

At NVIDIA's Editor's Day this year, it was pointed out that under certain conditions, ATI cards will not render detail textures on objects very close to the viewer, while NVIDIA cards would. This issue has been clarified for us by EPIC. The problem occurs when the LOD setting in UT2K3 is above 0.5, which affects ATI's mipmapping algorithm differently than NVIDIA's (ATI cards never rendered the highest detail mipmap under these conditions). With the LOD set below 0.5, there is no problem with ATI rendering detail textures.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1205 (Wayback Machine).