Archive 1997–2024

Voodoo Envy M:855 Part 1 - Athlon 64 DTR and Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro

Splinter Cell IQ - 1_1_2Tbilisi

Splinter Cell has three codepaths: Class 2, Class 1, and Class 0. ATI’s Rxx and R3xx use the Class 1 codepath, while NVIDIA’s NV2x and NV3x use the Class 2 codepath.

Class 2 Graphic Adaptors:
NV2x/NV3x chips
Dynamic Lighting system = Shadow Buffer
Vertex position modifiers = Yes
Light beams stopped by depth texturing = Yes
Pixel Shader effects/filters/water = Yes
Reflection/Details texturing/Specular = Yes

Class 1 Graphic Adaptors:
R2xx/R3xx/Parhelia/Xabre 200/Xabre 400/Xabre 600/chips/Creative P9
Dynamic Lighting system = Shadow Projector
Vertex position modifiers = No
Light beams stopped by depth texturing = No
Pixel Shader effects/filters/water = Yes
Reflection/Details texturing/Specular = Yes

This does means that some visual effects will be different between the two hardware solutions, as the codepaths are different. Class 2 graphic adapters can run as Class 2, Class 1, and Class 0, while Class 1 graphic adapters can run as Class 1 and Class 0. Forced emulation is possible, but by default, the hardware will chose the appropriate codepath intended. We ran everything by default, which means that two different codepaths were used.

We originally believed that the Class 2 graphic adapters would output a possibly higher image quality then Class 1, due to the naming derivative. However, the image quality issue isn’t all black and white. Instead, we have found scenarios that seem support both sides of the spectrum.

The last pair of pictures shows a stark example between the two codepaths. NVIDIA’s GeForce FX Go5650 won’t show the explosion of the computer when shot at, while ATI’s Mobility Radeon 9600 and Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro will. This is concurrent in the desktop products, as well. So it seems that ATI’s hardware is doing more work in this scenario, despite still coming out well on top (even when considering the CPU scaling). Meanwhile, the pixel shader use seems to be a bit more smoothed out on NVIDIA hardware (the first and second pair of pictures), but we do have some reservations over the quality of the pixel shaders used. We will let you be the judge...

Voodoo Envy M:855 - Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro

Click to enlarge.

Dell Inspiron 8600 - GeForce FX Go5650

Click to enlarge.

Voodoo Envy M:855 - Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro

Click to enlarge.

Dell Inspiron 8600 - GeForce FX Go5650

Click to enlarge.

Voodoo Envy M:855 - Mobility Radeon 9600 Pro

Click to enlarge.

Dell Inspiron 8600 - GeForce FX Go5650

Click to enlarge.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1191 (Wayback Machine).