Archive 1997–2024

Fall 2003 Video Card Roundup - Part 2: High End Shootout

Aquamark3 IQ

Aquamark3 is a synthetic benchmark based on a game called Aquanox, and it uses the DX9 API. In Part 1 we included it for completeness, but our main focus this time around is image quality. There have been lots of IQ problems found around the net that have helped earn NVIDIAs 51.xx drivers the title "cheatenators". With the 52.14 drivers we have been using, we didn't notice any image quality issues on a visual inspection, which was a very good sign, Lets take a closer look at frame 4000 to point out problems:

 

NVIDIA 45.23

Note the ground around the explosion

 

NVIDIA 52.14

Note the difference between the new and old drivers

 

ATI Catalyst 3.7

Identical to NVIDIA

As we can see, the lighting problem that was once there no longer exists, and the image is consistent with what it should be. On top of this, the 52.14 drivers give us about a more than 50% performance improvement over the 45.23 drivers. We have to remember that this is a benchmark, and any company that wants to sell anything is going to try to fix benchmark problems first. Of course, that's just anther reason I really don't like synthetic benchmarks: I'd rather have NVIDIA and ATI hard at work on the games I'm playing rather than on something I'll never care about using.

Here we can also see a comparison of the images with the highest quality AA setting in the game and 8xAF:

NVIDIA 45.23

NVIDIA 52.14

ATI Catalyst 3.7

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1174 (Wayback Machine).