Archive 1997–2024

ASUS DRW-0402P/D: ASUS joins the dual format fray


Write Speeds

 

Click to enlarge.

CD Speed determining the burn speed of a CDR.



Below are the CD-R, CD+RW, DVD+R, DVD+RW, DVD-R and DVD-RW speed tests. We used CD Speed with the same configuration as the previous test.

Average Transfer Media Length
ASUS 52X CDR Data CD 15.97X 79.49.74
PNY 52X CDR Data CD 15.95X 79.49.74
Mitsubishi 32X CDRW Data CD N/A 73:43.00
Mitsubishi 24X CDRW Data CD N/A 73:43.00
FujiFilm 12X CDRW Data CD 8.33X 73:43.00
FujiFilm 4X DVD-R Data CD 4.01X 4.38GB
Bundled (Generic?) 4X DVD-R Data CD 4.00X 4.38GB
TDK 4X DVD-R Data CD 4.02X 4.38GB
FujiFilm 4X DVD+R Data CD 4.01X 4.38GB
Imation 4X DVD+R Data CD 2.95X 4.38GB
FujiFilm 4X DVD-RW Data CD 1.95X 4.38GB
FujiFilm 2.4X DVD+RW Data CD 2.46X 4.38GB

Obviously, the ASUS DRW was not capable of burning all of our media at the speeds for which the media was rated. Obviously, some of our 12X CDRW media was bumped down to 10X as the maximum CD rewrite speed. However, the most obvious problem was with the Mitsubishi CDRW media. Typically, we regard this as very high quality CDRW media, but for whatever reason, the A06 completely refused to write or acknowledge the media as rewriteable. Reading from the Mitsubishi disks was no problem.

Another thing that kept us reserved was the unusual write speeds on some media. For example, our 4X rated Imation DVD+R media would only write around 3X, while FujiFilm disks had no problem writing at 4X. Keep in mind that FujiFilm DVD media is not nearly as high caliber as some of the other disks we used in this benchmark. Further tests confirmed that the drive inaccurately would not recognize other 4X DVD-R and DVD+R media from TDK, PNY and Imation. These inconsistencies in media would probably be solved by firmware upgrades. Feel free to check out the DWR 1.05 BIOS revision spreadsheet, DVR106D FW History Rev105.xls. As you can see, this drive has had a history of problems with various media. It would be wise to purchase only media for this drive that is mentioned in the Changelog as working.

Below is a sample write test with FujiFilm 2.4X DVD+RW disks that were recognized as DVD+R by CD Speed. The burner had no problem at 2.46X.


Click to enlarge.


Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1159 (Wayback Machine).