Archive 1997–2024

Sizing Up Servers: Intel's Skylake-SP Xeon versus AMD's EPYC 7000 - The Server CPU Battle of the Decade?

Intel's Optimized Turbo Profiles

Also new to Skylake-SP, Intel has also further enhanced turbo boosting.

There are also some security and virtualization enhancements (MBE, PPK, MPX) , but these are beyond the scope this article as we don't test them. 

Summing It All Up: How Skylake-SP and Zen Compare

The table below shows you the differences in a nutshell.

  AMD EPYC 7000
 
Intel Skylake-SP Intel Broadwell-EP
 
Package & Dies Four dies in one MCM Monolithic  Monolithic
Die size 4x 195 mm² 677 mm² 456 mm²
On-Chip Topology Infinity Fabric
(1-Hop Max)
Mesh Dual Ring
Socket configuration 1-2S 1-8S ("Platinum") 1-2S
Interconnect (Max.)
Bandwidth (*)(Max.)
4x16 (64) PCIe lanes
4x 37.9 GB/s
3x UPI 20 lanes
3x 41.6 GB/s
2x QPI 20 lanes
2x 38.4 GB/s
TDP 120-180W 70-205W 55-145W
8-32 4-28 4-22
LLC (max.) 64MB (8x8 MB) 38.5 MB 55 MB
Max. Memory 2 TB 1.5 TB 1.5 TB
Memory subsystem
Fastest sup. DRAM
8 channels
DDR4-2666
6 channels
DDR4-2666
4 channels
DDR4-2400
PCIe Per CPU in a 2P 64 PCIe (available) 48 PCIe 3.0 40 PCIe 3.0

(*) total bandwidth (bidirectional)

At a high level, I would argue that Intel has the most advanced multi-core topology, as they're capable of integrating up to 28 cores in a mesh. The mesh topology will allow Intel to add more cores in future generations while scaling consistently in most applications. The last level cache has a decent latency and can accommodate applications with a massive memory footprint. The latency difference between accessing a local L3-cache chunk and one further away is negligible on average, allowing the L3-cache to be a central storage for fast data synchronization between the L2-caches. However, the highest performing Xeons are huge, and thus expensive to manufacture. 

AMD's MCM approach is much cheaper to manufacture. Peak memory bandwidth and capacity is quite a bit higher with 4 dies and 2 memory channels per die. However, there is no central last level cache that can perform low latency data coordination between the L2-caches of the different cores (except inside one CCX). The eight 8 MB L3-caches acts like - relatively low latency - spill over caches for the 32 L2-caches on one chip.  

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/11544/intel-skylake-ep-vs-amd-epyc-7000-cpu-battle-of-the-decade (Wayback Machine).