Archive 1997–2024

2003 Power Supply Roundup Part II: Better Faster Cheaper

An alarming trend we noticed with our roundup was that power supplies with fan controls on the rear of the unit have problems keeping tight tolerances.  We looked into the problem a little more and noticed that while the components on the inside of the unit were of good quality, the fan control switches themselves were not. 

Often the worst cases were fan control power supplies with often poor locking mechanisms.  For example, the TTGI power supplies sometimes let the control switch slip slightly, resulting in a switch that rested half way between “high” and “low”.  As a result, the poor contact produced incredibly awful ripple tests as demonstrated below.

Fan Control out of Place Voltages

 

+12V Low

+12V High

Kingwin KWI-450WABK

11.830

12.225

TTGI/SuperFlower 520SS 4Fan

11.820

12.240

TTGI/SuperFlower 420SS

11.850

12.225

TTGI/SuperFlower 350SS

11.875

12.305

Vantec Ion 400W

11.780

12.005

Vantec Stealth 520W

11.750

12.010

Edit:Although these measurements do not show the +12V rail out of specification from the ATX12V 1.2 document, they are much different from the measurements obtained on the previous page. This change warrants some attention, since if unchecked, poor signals will damage your hardware.  Newer motherboards attempt to purify signals coming on the motherboard to prevent catastrophic failure, but voltages over the rails not feeding to the motherboard are very susceptible to failure (this puts a video card or hard drive in serious jeopardy). 

After contacting manufacturers with this information, we got confirmation from companies stating that they planned on dropping the fan control from their power supplies.  Vantec told us that dropping this controller actually lowers their cost significantly, and the savings would be then relayed to the consumer.  Consider how much you actually use the fan control on your power supply (if you have one).  Our opinion is that the tradeoff will be well worth it.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1124 (Wayback Machine).