Archive 1997–2024

Searching for the Memory Holy Grail: Part 1


Intel White Papers Confirm Results

We have seen that SiSoft Sandra UNBuffered Memory benchmarks show four DIMMs to perform better than two in all configurations at DDR400 or higher base speeds on the 875/865 chipsets. However, MemTest86 Bandwidth and Sandra Standard Memory benchmark do not show improvement in going from two to four double-sided DIMMs. So why do we believe Sandra UNBuffered Memory benchmarks?

The answer, surprisingly, is in Intel 875P Chipset Memory Configuration Guide White Paper and the Intel 865P Chipset Memory Configuration Guide White Paper. The tables below are taken from Page 13 of the 875P White Paper, but the tables are identical in both the 865 and 875 documents, except that the first and second positions are reversed in the DDR400 chart for the 865. The Intel performance rankings exactly match the rankings we have measured using SiSoft Sandra UNBuffered Memory Test. It is interesting that UNBuffered Sandra was able to distinguish the performance differences between #1 and #2 –- four double-sided vs. two double-sided. This performance distinction was not apparent in either MemTest86 Bandwidth or SiSoft Sandra Standard Memory Test.

DDR400 Performance Configurations on Intel 875/865
from Intel White Papers
DDR Speed Number of DIMMS Sides per DIMM Mode SC or DC Performance
400 MHz 4 2 Dynamic Dual Channel 1
(2 for 865)
400 MHz 2 2 Dynamic Dual Channel 2
(1 for 865)
400 MHz 4 1 Dynamic Dual Channel 2
400 MHz 2 1 Dynamic Dual Channel 3
400 MHz 4 any Normal Dual Channel 4
400 MHz any 2 Dynamic Single Channel 5
400 MHz any 1 Dynamic Single Channel 6
400 MHz any any Normal Single Channel 7

DDR266/333 Performance Configurations on Intel 875/865
from Intel White Papers
DDR Speed Number of DIMMS Sides per DIMM Mode SC or DC Performance
233/333 MHz 2 2 Dynamic Dual Channel 1
233/333 MHz 4 1 Dynamic Dual Channel 1
233/333 MHz 2 1 Dynamic Dual Channel 2
233/333 MHz 4 2 Dynamic Dual Channel 3
233/333 MHz any any Normal Dual Channel 4
233/333 MHz 2
(1 in each channel)
any Dynamic Single Channel 5
233/333 MHz 1 2 Dynamic Single Channel 5
233/333 MHz any 1 Dynamic Single Channel 6
233/333 MHz any any Normal Single Channel 7

While we didn’t test Asynchronous 5:4 or 3:2 performance, or Memory Performance when using a 533FSB CPU, the DDR266/333 table should be useful for those situations. When running DDR333/266 as a base speed, two double-sided DIMMS or four single-sided DIMMS perform the fastest. Two single-sided DIMMs are second in speed performance, and four double-sided DIMMs – the fastest performer at DDR400 and higher – drops to third place.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1122 (Wayback Machine).