Archive 1997–2024

The GIGABYTE X170-Extreme ECC Motherboard Review: For When Skylake Xeons need SLI and Thunderbolt 3

GIGABYTE X170-Extreme ECC Conclusion

When GIGABYTE announced its X170 line of motherboards with server chipsets back at CES in January 2016, I was relatively skeptical. Here was a prosumer product with an odd name (there's no X170 chipset for a start), in camouflage attire being marketed to consumers. A number of motherboard companies had approached me questioning the size of the mainstream Xeon market (ie the E3-1200 market), but GIGABYTE nevertheless went in feet first with this design. Alongside the big X170-Extreme ECC we've looked at in this review, there is also a C232 based ATX version and a micro-ATX in the same family. Nonetheless the X170-Extreme ECC is the only one motherboard on the market that supports SLI, Thunderbolt 3 and Xeon CPUs all at the same time.

Asking around about the prevalence of SLI in the E3-1200 Xeon market, and most motherboard manufacturers dismissed it as a small number. The answer I got most of the time is that any user that requires 2+ GPUs is typically doing so in OpenCL mode, not for gaming, which wouldn't require SLI. As an example I was cited a handful of C236 motherboards that support x8/x8 via bifurcation of the CPU PCIe lanes.

For the GIGABYTE X170-Extreme ECC, if you need SLI with Thunderbolt 3 and a Skylake E3-1200 v5 Xeon, it is your only option. Nonetheless, it still comes across as a well-equipped motherboard, and excels in some of our benchmarks, such as POST time where it tops the table. Unfortunately the are some tumbles, such as the DPC Latency at 250 microseconds.

$310 is still a lot for a motherboard. Bearing that in mind, and that we have awarded $500 motherboards this generation, it is clear where the GIGABYTE X170-Extreme ECCs selling points lie. If you want a server grade chipset with ECC and SLI support, as well as Thunderbolt 3, this is one of the few off the shelf options available. Unlike most server offerings (like the MW31-SP0), it behaves with the user experience of a similarly priced consumer product, which is what we used to expect before Intel made the transition for Xeon E3 CPUs to enterprise chipsets only.

Other 100-Series and C232/C236 Motherboard Reviews:
Prices Correct at time of each review

$500: The GIGABYTE Z170X-Gaming G1 Review [link]
$500: The ASUS Maximus VIII Extreme Review [link]
$370: The GIGABYTE Server MW31-SP0 (C236) Review [link]
$310: The GIGABYTE X170-Extreme ECC Review [this review]
$250: The ASUS Maximus VIII Impact Review [link]
$240: The ASRock Z170 Extreme7+ Review [link]
$230: The MSI Z170 Gaming M7 Review [link]
$208: The GIGABYTE Z170-UD5 TH Review [link]
$165: The ASUS Z170-A Review [link]
$143: The ASRock E3V5 Gaming (C232) Review [link]
$130: The MSI Z170A SLI PLUS Review [link]
$125: The Supermicro C7H170-M Review [link]

 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/10764/the-gigabyte-x170-extreme-ecc-motherboard-review (Wayback Machine).