Archive 1997–2024

Windows XP Media Center Edition: Exposed

Introducing Media Center Edition

Much like Tablet PC Edition, Media Center Edition (MCE) is largely based on the Windows XP Professional kernel. In fact, if you strip away the Media Center part of the equation you will be left with a fully functional copy of Windows XP Professional. What Media Center adds to the OS is primarily support for the Media Center application, which appears as nothing more than a regular program in your Start Menu.

There’s much more to MCE than the Media Center application however; for starters, MCE uses a nonstandard codec for compressing all of the shows it records. Fundamentally, all programming is recorded in an MPEG-2 format with an ASF wrapper; Microsoft’s ASF (Advanced Systems Format) works perfectly in this case as it can act as nothing more than a container for media encoded in a different format, more specially MPEG-2 encoded audio and video.

The ASF wrapper effectively prevents two things from happening with the shows that MCE records; first of all, you can playback anything recorded in MCE but the playback system must be able to read this unique ASF wrapped file format. Currently, the only application that supports playback of MCE recorded files is Windows Media Player 9.

The ASF wrapper also currently prevents transcoding into other media formats, such as DiVX. We’d expect this to change eventually but currently you’re stuck with the “bloated” MPEG-2 encoded video. One of the benefits of a PC based PVR, as we mentioned before, is the ability to transcode and store your recorded shows in whatever format you desire – especially in DiVX/MPEG-4 formats, something no other PVR can currently do.

Playback of MCE recorded files on the MCE machine itself doesn’t require Windows Media Player 9, rather just the MCE application and a specific MPEG-2 codec. For whatever reason, version 3.0 of Intervideo’s WinDVD has the appropriate MPEG-2 codec necessary for MCE. What’s even more confusing is that WinDVD 4.0 will not work, as MCE will complain about not being able to find the appropriate playback codec. And no, installing WinDVD 3.0 on another computer won’t let you playback MCE recorded files, you need to actually have MCE installed for that to work.

That pretty much sums it up for the software side of MCE; not to discount the amazing amount of work that has gone into MCE, as we’ll be getting to the incredible interface shortly, but as you can see there’s not much to it at a high level.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1051 (Wayback Machine).